They Can't See the Page: More Basic Reasons Poor Kids Struggle to Learn
One in twenty students has trouble focusing well enough to read without trouble. How are kids supposed to learn if they can't see the page?
This isn't new information. We've known about the "vision problem" for years.
In fact, not surprisingly, for poor children this problem, is much worse.
Research indicates that:
How much of the challenge that poor kids face in learning results from incredibly basic causes that have nothing to do with pedaogy (or even with more subtle issues like cultural mismatch, etc.).
How about the relationship between vision and "delinquent" kids?
What an incredible tragedy. Even on these most basic levels we find it impossible to support these children.
Read more →
This isn't new information. We've known about the "vision problem" for years.
In fact, not surprisingly, for poor children this problem, is much worse.
Research indicates that:
50% of low-income kids have untreated vision problems
In some underserved areas, the number of children who fall through the cracks is staggering. Optometrists volunteering through the Lions Club found that 47 percent of children had vision problems in schools in West Los Angeles.And you can't catch these problems with the cursory exams usually done in schools:
Many lay people confuse a vision screening with a vision exam, although the former is but a procedure that's supposed to identify those children who may need further examination. However, the screenings many schools administer even fall short of that. Vision screenings that test only acuity detect 30 percent of children who would fail a professional examIn fact, cursory exams may actually exacerbate the problem, indicating that a child can see fine and reducing the chance that she will get a comprehensive exam. In other words, poor exams may actually ensure that the problem is never corrected.
How much of the challenge that poor kids face in learning results from incredibly basic causes that have nothing to do with pedaogy (or even with more subtle issues like cultural mismatch, etc.).
How about the relationship between vision and "delinquent" kids?
A key finding was that almost all of the 132 delinquents in the study had learning related vision problems, but only a few had nearsightedness, farsightedness or astigmatism. Common in teens, these refractive problems are a sign that the person has made adaptations to deal with the stress of close work in the classroom. . . .How much of the achievement gap could be eliminated with comprehensive health care, breakfast, and nutrition?
The lack of such problems in these delinquents indicates that, at any early age, they chose not to deal with close work, Dr. Harris said. Other study findings show the reason why. They simply lacked the vision skills to do close work.
What an incredible tragedy. Even on these most basic levels we find it impossible to support these children.
Mike Rose on McCain on Education
Interview with Mike Rose who wrote Possible Lives and Lives on the Boundary. His blog is here with more comments in the leading post.
Read more →
ACORN, Organizing, and Education
My writing on community organizing now mostly appears on Open Left. But a couple of my fellow bloggers asked me to write something on ACORN, the national community organizing group that is currently under attack for its voter registration work.
The right wing is attacking ACORN not only because of its voter registration work, but because it is one of if not THE most important community organizing groups in America.
Unlike other national groups, ACORN generates its membership by knocking on doors, one after the other, not by organizing organizations like churches. As a result, its local membership is usually more broadly representative of poor and working-class people in America. Also unlike other groups, it participates actively in national campaigns and policy debates and does not just operate as an umbrella training and support organization.
ACORN is not a 501(c)3 organization, which means it can integrate political AND issue work, something most other organizing groups cannot do. ACORN is also one of the publishers of Social Policy.
ACORN and Education
ACORN has done extensive work on education, including running their own schools, national policy studies and reports, local studies (pdf), and, of course, direct . action for educational . change.
This report (pdf) is a few years old, now, but gives a sense of the range of educational issues ACORN engages with.
Note: I haven't had much direct involvement with ACORN, and I'm not really up on their current activities.
Those new to my organizing posts may want to read Part I and Part II of "What is Organizing?".
Read more →
The right wing is attacking ACORN not only because of its voter registration work, but because it is one of if not THE most important community organizing groups in America.
Unlike other national groups, ACORN generates its membership by knocking on doors, one after the other, not by organizing organizations like churches. As a result, its local membership is usually more broadly representative of poor and working-class people in America. Also unlike other groups, it participates actively in national campaigns and policy debates and does not just operate as an umbrella training and support organization.
ACORN is not a 501(c)3 organization, which means it can integrate political AND issue work, something most other organizing groups cannot do. ACORN is also one of the publishers of Social Policy.
ACORN and Education
ACORN has done extensive work on education, including running their own schools, national policy studies and reports, local studies (pdf), and, of course, direct . action for educational . change.
This report (pdf) is a few years old, now, but gives a sense of the range of educational issues ACORN engages with.
Note: I haven't had much direct involvement with ACORN, and I'm not really up on their current activities.
Those new to my organizing posts may want to read Part I and Part II of "What is Organizing?".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
